Prosecutors said Matt Araiza was not present when an alleged gang rape of a minor occurred at an October 2021 party, according to witness testimony included in evidence that prompted the San Diego District Attorney to not press criminal charges against the former Buffalo Bills punter.
Araiza, a former punter at San Diego State, also was not visible in any of the videos recovered from the night in question, according to audio from a meeting between San Diego deputy district attorney Trisha Amador and the woman who filed a civil lawsuit last year against Araiza and two of his former Aztecs teammates.
ESPN has obtained and reviewed over 1 hour and 41 minutes worth of audio from the Dec. 7, 2022, meeting attended by Amador, the woman, the woman’s attorney, District Attorney investigator Ted Mansour and a selected victim advocate.
Amador told the woman that Araiza left the off-campus party about an hour before the time of the alleged gang rape, according to a witness.
Amador said Araiza is “alleged to have left the party at 12:30” and was not “even at the party anymore” when the alleged gang rape occurred at 1:30 a.m. PT, according to video time stamps of the encounter.
Amador also told the woman that nobody outside of her office, including the witness who testified to Araiza’s departure from the party, knows about the specific time stamps of the videos recovered from the party.
“There’s a witness who doesn’t have a reason to say what time suspect Araiza left the party because nobody knows about the time stamps — that he would’ve left the party prior to [a video being filmed],” Amador told the woman, according to the audio.
The Bills released Araiza on Aug. 27, two days after a civil lawsuit was filed accusing him of having sex with the then-17-year-old woman who was under the age of consent in California.
The lawsuit states that Araiza, who was 21 at the time, led the woman to the side of the house and told her to perform oral sex on him before they had sexual intercourse. According to the lawsuit, Araiza then took her inside the home, where at least three other men, including the other two defendants named in the suit — former Aztecs teammates Zavier Leonard and Nowlin Ewaliko — were located, and that she was repeatedly raped for about 1½ hours.
The woman reported the alleged rape the following day to the San Diego Police Department, which investigated the allegations for nine months before turning over its investigation to prosecutors on Aug. 5, 2022.
According to a transcript of a pretext phone call between Araiza and the woman recorded on Oct. 27, 2021, Araiza said that after he the woman “hooked up,” then he remained outside “for the rest of the party.”
The videos recorded from the party were described as taking place inside the house in two separate rooms, with about nine clips of “point of view videos” taken from the perspective of those engaging in the acts, recovered from multiple devices. Some of them are in a Snapchat format.
“I didn’t really see you again, but I remember somebody saying that like you were yelling at someone, or you were angry,” Araiza said to the woman, according to the transcript. “And like then the party was going to end or something like that. I think that was the reason the party ended.”
In April, a judge agreed to unseal the videos but not release them to the public, according to the San Diego Union Tribune. That order, however, will not go into effect until the end of this week to allow for an appeal to filed.
The District Attorney’s office also was unable to prove that there was awareness of the then-17-year-old woman’s age or her intoxication level. At least two witnesses at the party allegedly heard the woman say she was 18, while others said they didn’t recall her age coming up.
“The DA’s Sex Crimes and Human Trafficking Division has a team of Deputy District Attorneys, District Attorney Investigators, and Victim Advocates who are trained on how to be trauma-informed when interacting with victims,” Tanya Sierra, assistant director of communications for San Diego County District Attorney’s Office, said in a statement. “It’s a priority for our office that we treat victims with dignity, respect, courtesy, and sensitivity.
“Even in instances where we cannot file charges because we cannot prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt, we reach out to the victims so they can meet with us so we can explain why the case cannot be filed and answer their questions. We also offer them trauma-informed services through our Victim Services Unit and at One Safe Place: The North County Family Justice Center.”
Araiza has filed a claim against San Diego State University for damage to his reputation, according to a document reviewed by ESPN.
Witness says Matt Araiza wasn’t present at time of alleged rape